13May2009
Ratiopharm v. Sepracor, District Court The Hague (Rechtbank Den Haag), 13 May 2009
- By Mark van Gardingen, Brinkhof,
for Kluwer IP Cases
The Hague District Court nullified Sepracor’s patent for compositions for treating allergic disorders using (-) cetirizine (levociterizine) on the basis of lack of inventive step. The Court considered that the person skilled in the art knows that the pharmaceutical efficacy of a racemic mixture generally can be attributed to one of the enantiomers. At the priority date the skilled person would have researched the antihistamic activity of levoceterizine with his common general knowledge as his ‘tools’ and would have come to the claimed invention. Researching the individual enantiomers is therefore obvious and cannot lead to the grant of a patent.
The full text and summary of this case will be posted on http://www.KluwerIPCases.comom.
Comment Preview